 |
Positive Feedback ISSUE 55
may/june
2011
 |
The Future Is
Here Audio Still Rules
by
Karl Lozier
Blu-ray recordings may
be video, audio or most commonly video plus audio.
If the video is a distraction turn it off though I
would suggest watching the video at least once; at
times it can be interesting or entertaining. Naxos
is again following up with more high definition (Blu-ray)
audio only releases. For many listeners that will be
a distinct improvement in audio quality if the HDMI
digital output signal is used instead of the analog.
That one cable carries everything including stereo
or multi-channel audio in addition to the very high
quality Blu-ray video signal. Greater clarity and a
smoother treble will be noticed with many if not
most home audio systems. So far this seems to be
consistently true. Easier connection when that one
cable is appreciated by all. Sometimes new-fangled
things are even easier to use while offering better
quality, at least in the audio/musical field.
An easy way to get into
the beauty and audio and video qualities of Blu-ray
releases is by getting a truly good player (a good
start is important with many things in this old
world) a very decent AV receiver such as by Onkyo,
Integra, Denon and others that have multiple HDMI
cable inputs and good digital or digital to analog
connections and jump right in. Your newer television
sets will have the correct and simple HDMI
connections for simplified setup. The AV receiver
will let you add surround sound easily. Remember
that quality is more important than quantity in the
long run.
Notice the generally
favorable brief reviews I write each issue? There
are logical reasons for that to happen. Changes such
as digital and HDMI connections have made pretty
darn good audio to be easier for the manufacturers
to give us and easier for us to put to use. Same is
true for the video portion that we pretty well take
for granted here. As you purchase and use some of my
suggested performances you may notice that
relatively unknown sources and performers are often
doing a superb job and why not! Unlike many of the
big professional outfits and famous performers they
can and possibly do practice for many months on end,
repeating the same music or performances. That can
be the way for an individual, or group, chorus or
orchestra to be discovered by being on these well
done Blu-ray recordings! Pay attention, watch and
listen to the possible stars of the near future in
the comfort of your own listening and viewing room.

Richard Wagner-Die
Meistersinger von Nurnberg. Orchestra: Bayreuth
Festival and Chorus. Conductor: Sebastian Weigle.
Opus Arte Blu-ray OA BD 7078D
Marius Petipa's-La
Bayadere. Orchestra: Royal Opera House. Conductor:
Valeriy Ovsyanikov. Opus Arte Blu-ray BD 7079D
Dvorak-Symphonies
Nos. 6 and 9. Orchestra: Baltimore Symphony.
Conductor: Marin Alsop. Naxos Blu-ray NBD 1400

Chopin- Piano
Concerto No.1, Fantasia and Krakowiak. Orchestra:
Warsaw Philharmonic. Conductor: Antoni Wit. Pianist:
Eldar Nebolsin. Naxos Blue-ray NBD 0011
Saint-Saens Samson et
Dalila. Orchestra: Symphony and Choir of Vlaamse
Opera Antwerp/Ghent. Conductor: Tomas Netopil.
EuroArts 2058628
Walter Braunfels-The
Birds. Orchestra: Los Angeles Opera and Chorus.
Conductor: James Conlon. Art Haus Blu-ray 101 530

Beethoven-Missa
Solemnis. Orchestra: Staatskapelle Dresden and Opera
Chorus. Conductor: Christian Thielemann. CMajor Blu-ray
705504

Brahms-Violin
Concerto + Dvorak-Symphony No.9 "From the New
World." Orchestra: Berlin Philharmoniker. Conductor:
Claudio Abbado. EuroArts Blu-ray 2051954
Minkus-don Quichot (
Don Quixote). Orchestra: Holland Symfonia.
Conductor: Kevin Rhodes. ArtHaus Blu-ray 101 562
Wagner was famous and
rightly so for his tremendous and unique "Ring
Cycle" of music dramas. Before, during and after
that he composed some relatively traditional operas.
Die Meistersinger as you may have guessed simply
translates as the master singer. The town is having
a contest to determine which of three male
contestants will become Die Meistersinger. The local
goldsmith offers his daughter to marry the winner as
an added inducement. The three interested men
include the comical town clerk, an aristocrat and an
aging shoemaker. You may start to dream up dramatic
and comical vocal situations with that odd group and
hear what Wagner did with them. Every vocalist has a
richly projecting voice and the orchestra holds up
its part excellently. I find no audio problems to
mar listening enjoyment. Do not expect to find a
traditional stage setting; ‘rather contemporary'
fills the bill just fine with excellent video
quality, though not particularly outstanding in any
respect.
Neither the name Marius
Petipa nor La Bayadere was even mentioned in any of
my small collection of reference books and others of
my favorite musical sources; not even my revised
edition of The Oxford Dictionary of Music. I dislike
using the internet for musical things like this
though you are encouraged to do so. This ballet
translates as "The Temple Dancer" and was first
performed in 1877 by the Imperial Ballet at the
Imperial Bolshoi Theater in St. Petersburg, Russia.
The music is mainly by Ludwig Minkus and
orchestrated by John Lanchbery. That says a great
deal in my opinion. So far everything I have heard
orchestrated by Lanchbery has been done with an eye
or ear to the likes of typical audiences, very
lyrical and using very attractive instrumentation.
So it goes here and with the exotic costuming and
setting in India, this very appealing production
with fine video and audio may restore interest. It
certainly caught both my visual attention as well as
audio as I am always on the lookout for something
new and appealing. Here it is and odds are that you
too will enjoy it thoroughly. Yes, the audio is fine
with no significant quibbles as seems to be very
common with most of the newer Blu-ray releases.
The Naxos Blu-ray audio
only release offers great value and a great quantity
of attractive music though it should be clear that
the most interest lies with the Symphony No.9 (From
the New World); that is an obvious reference to the
USA. I think every classical listener should own a
copy of that composition. Here it is combined with
the less popular No.6 as a real bargain. Some
listeners attribute at least some of the lack of
popularity to a perceived borrowing from Brahms'
symphony No.2 written in the same key, of D major.
An all-around good choice, this performance of the
(New World) symphony is not quite good enough to
recommend replacing a personal favorite with it. The
generally fine audio quality is also not quite the
equal of the best newly released Blu-ray releases.
As you listen to this symphony, keep your mind
active trying to catch the famous "Go'n Home" folk
music theme heard rather repeatedly.
This new release of this
beautiful Chopin Piano Concerto No.1 features the
first recorded use of the new Polish National Chopin
Edition. Chopin was well known to not have the
personal ability to powerfully perform many piano
compositions including some of his own. Most of his
compositions feature great lyrical and melodic music
as opposed to the feeling of power and force. That
is very obvious here with excellent performances by
Antoni Wit, as all three compositions share the
other qualities made famous by Chopin. The excellent
Warsaw Philharmonic sounded very polished and fully
up to the recording demands accompanying Wit. The
audio quality is quite excellent and particularly
excelling in great unforced clarity in the treble
range and the sensation of very adequate orchestral
power. Definitely a top quality Blu-ray release
obviously showing off the very real potential
compared to regular CDs. A particularly fine piano
performance, it is combined with recorded audio
quality revealing every note with near perfection.
Of course my recommendation is easily and deservedly
given. Even beginning classical music listeners
should readily appreciate the beauty revealed here
with great detail.
Here I need to mention
an addition at no extra cost to our loyal
subscribers. Going through the many Blu-ray releases
recently sent to me I wound up viewing and listening
to one that was not Blu-ray! In fact there may not
even be a Blu-ray version available. As you may know
most Blu-ray releases are also released in DVD. In
this case what I listened to and viewed has PCM
Stereo and Dolby Digital 5.0. How close it might
come to a future Blu-ray release of the release, I
know not. The vocalists were outstanding and unknown
to me. After the okay initial run through, I did not
do my usual audio only session. This update of
Samson and Dalila is moved to the Middle-East and in
contemporary context. Subtle changes such as our
modern Samson, instead of pushing the supporting
pillars of the temple down, is shown with a complete
body surround pack of explosives ready to use…Also
Samson did not have long hair. The Birds does
feature birds and is described as a lyric fantastic
play in two acts after Aristophanes, the greatest
ancient satirical writer. The music is interesting
and appropriate. The set designs are also very
fitting and attractive. The story of two men
searching for birds and finding them, and possibly
themselves, reveals stunningly beautiful costumes
often the equal of that seen in some ballets. The
visual may be the equal of the fine audio in this
unusual release. It is definitely bird oriented. The
sublimely outstanding Beethoven's Missa Solemnis as
Beethoven wrote on the autograph score " From the
heart-may it go to the heart!" I would probably be
able to find minor quibbles with this overall
excellent performance with repeated listening.
Initially with the excellent hi-def video vying for
my senses, I am happy with it; I recommend it even
if used only for the 5.1 surround audio quality. It
remains to be decided just how good it is; it has
been quite awhile since a really good Missa arrived.
This release actually
starts off with a decent performance of Beethoven's
Egmont overture. These performances were recorded
nine years ago, possibly preceding Gil Shaham's rise
to fame mastering the violin here in the tough
Brahms concerto. Good all around, it may not quite
replace your favorite recording though it sure has a
lot going for it if you want to get your first
Brahms concerto. The Dvorak ninth symphony "From the
New World" (USA) has Abbado intensely immersed with
the Berlin Philharmonic. Visually and audibly he is
giving his all even in the softer lyrical passages.
This Blu-ray recording just may be right up top with
any other I am familiar with. Excellent audio is
available from the HDMI outputs and it would be a
rare analog connection and player to surpass it.
Highly recommended, but it does not end there! As an
encore Abbado adds the rather rare Verdi Overture to
the Sicilian Vespers. It is a gem not to be missed
in a great performance and superbly recorded. Get
it. The ballet Don Quixote is also based on the well
known Cervantes story of the very likable Don
rescuing damsels he perceives as being in distress
and in his spare time, tilting windmills with his
favorite lance. Very enjoyable fun here with fine
music, nice sets and costumes, make for a real
change of pace. Enjoy.
